Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Warner Bros. / DC (Matt Reeves) or the show's producers · how we work

RumorUpdated Nov 18, 2026 · 23 sources

Villain Leak Reports: Sebastian Stan as Victor Zsasz and Court of Owls

Multiple media outlets and fan communities are dissecting reported behind-the-scenes leaks that suggest Victor Zsasz, Two-Face, and the Court of Owls will appear in The Batman Part II, with Sebastian Stan rumored to play Zsasz or Harvey Dent.

How a Halloween Costume and Set Props Sparked Villain Rumors

Rumors about the villains in Matt Reeves' sequel began building in August 2026, when outlets including GamesRadar+ and GLITCHED reported that a set prop might have accidentally leaked the film's antagonists. Later that month, Comic Book Resources reported that the production teased the live-action movie debut of the Court of Owls.

The speculation escalated in early November 2026. According to reports from SlashFilm, Forbes, GQ, IMDb, and Cosmic Book News, a behind-the-scenes photo connected to Heidi Klum's Halloween costume preparation allegedly spoiled character details for The Batman Part II. Those reports stated that the leak teased Three major comic book elements: Victor Zsasz, Two-Face, and the Court of Owls.

Sebastian Stan's Role: Victor Zsasz or Harvey Dent?

In October 2026, The Hollywood Reporter noted that Sebastian Stan dropped hints about his role in The Batman Part II, quoting him as saying, "I hope it lands right." Following the November leak reports, GamesRadar+ and The Direct reported that a photo of a Sebastian Stan head sculpt strongly indicated he will play Victor Zsasz. The Direct also reported that DC took action to prevent spoilers from spreading online after the head sculpt photo surfaced.

Alongside the Zsasz reports, other outlets and fans focused on Two-Face and additional cast possibilities. IMDb reported that fans were convinced Matt Reeves had hinted at the sequel's Two-Face actor months earlier, while The Direct covered a theory that Charles Dance could suit up as a major DC supervillain in the Robert Pattinson sequel.

Fan Theories, Red Herrings, and Imposter Batman

Not everyone is taking the reported leaks at face value. GamesRadar+ reported that some DC fans believe the November leak is a red herring, arguing that proof can be found in the first movie. Meanwhile, a poster on the r/TheBatmanFilm subreddit pointed out that Batman's closing monologue in the first film about how "scars can destroy us" feels like a direct setup for Victor Zsasz.

On r/TheBatmanFilm, users also debated how Zsasz and Harvey Dent might fit into the plot. One fan noted that this would be the fifth live-action iteration of Zsasz and mentioned rumors that the character could act as a Batman imposter. Another Reddit theory proposed that Sebastian Stan is actually playing Harvey Dent, whose split personality caused by his father's abuse—with his father being a member of the Court of Owls—leads him to dress up as an imposter Batman before his transformation into Two-Face.

Two sides of the debate

The Leaks Point to Stan as Zsasz

  • The Direct and GamesRadar+ reported that a leaked photo of a Sebastian Stan head sculpt strongly indicates he is playing Victor Zsasz, and DC reportedly took action to stop the spoilers from spreading.
  • Multiple reports on the behind-the-scenes leak connected to Heidi Klum's Halloween costume preparation consistently name Victor Zsasz and the Court of Owls as featured villains.
  • Fans on r/TheBatmanFilm noted that Batman's closing quote about scars in the first movie sets up Zsasz, and expressed excitement over Matt Reeves adapting a disturbing serial killer villain.

It Is a Red Herring or a Harvey Dent Twist

  • GamesRadar+ reported that a segment of DC fans believes the November villain leak is a deliberate red herring, citing clues from the first film.
  • A fan theory on r/TheBatmanFilm argues that Sebastian Stan is actually playing Harvey Dent with a split personality linked to the Court of Owls, acting as an imposter Batman before becoming Two-Face.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: Who do you think Sebastian Stan is actually playing in The Batman Part II?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think the reported head sculpt leak confirms Sebastian Stan as Victor Zsasz, or are you buying into the fan theory that he is really playing Harvey Dent?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from The Batman II

ConfirmedAndy Serkis Confirms The Batman Part II Filming Extended into 2027Actor Andy Serkis has confirmed that the production schedule for Matt Reeves' The Batman Part II has been extended past Christmas and into 2027. Serkis also noted that he has not yet filmed his scenes as Alfred, shortly after wrapping his own directorial project.RumorRobert Pattinson's Bond Casting and Batman Part III ContractFollowing the official announcement that Robert Pattinson will play James Bond, multiple reports state that production delays on The Batman Part II allowed him to exit his contract for a third Batman film early. While some outlets and fans believe the trilogy is effectively over, other fans argue his high work output means he could still return.RumorDCU Shakeup: Gunn and Safran Exit Reports and Skydance Batman RumorsRecent fan discussions on r/TheBatmanFilm and r/batman center on reports of James Gunn and Peter Safran exiting as heads of DC film, alongside a report via NexusPointNews claiming Skydance wants to keep Robert Pattinson as its Batman in the DCU. These developments have sparked community debate about whether the Reevesverse will expand or face studio interference.ConfirmedMatt Reeves Steps Away and Steven Soderbergh Steps In to Finish FilmingFilming on The Batman Part II was temporarily paused in October 2026 when director Matt Reeves stepped away to handle a personal family matter. Ten days later, trade outlets reported that Steven Soderbergh joined the production to work with Reeves and complete filming, while James Gunn clarified that Reeves remains the film's director.